Understanding and Managing Risks in Commercial Construction: Key Insights for MGAs
The commercial construction industry is fraught with risks that can have significant financial implications for contractors, developers, and insurers. Managing these risks requires a deep understanding of the evolving landscape and the ability to calibrate risk priorities effectively. In this article, we’ll explore the top commercial construction risks that MGAs commonly underestimate or misunderstand, UK-specific considerations, claims and loss trends, and key underwriting information.
Top 7 Commercial Construction Risks MGAs Underestimate
- Builder’s Risk Exposure to CAT Events Isn’t Linear Anymore: The increasing frequency and severity of catastrophic events require MGAs to reassess their risk exposure and calibration.
- Soft Costs & Delay in Start-Up (DSU) Are Systemically Undervalued: Soft costs and delay in start-up can have a significant impact on project timelines and budgets, yet are often undervalued.
- Supply Chain Volatility Has Become a Loss Amplifier: Supply chain disruptions can amplify losses and increase the risk of project delays and cost overruns.
- Contractor Financial Fragility: Contractor financial instability can increase the risk of project abandonment, defects, and other issues.
- Design Liability Creep (Blurring of E&O and Construction Risk): The blurring of lines between design and construction risks can lead to increased liability and complexity.
- Latent Defects and ESG-Related Risks: Latent defects and ESG-related risks can have long-term implications for projects and insurers.
- Cladding/Remediation Exposure: The ongoing cladding remediation issue can have significant financial implications for developers, contractors, and insurers.
UK-Specific Considerations
The UK commercial construction market is subject to unique regulatory, legal, and market factors that impact risk. Some key considerations include:
- Building Safety Act impacts: The Building Safety Act has introduced new regulations and liabilities for developers, contractors, and insurers.
- Fire safety legislation: Fire safety regulations have become increasingly stringent, with significant implications for project design, construction, and operation.
- Planning delays, labour shortages, inflation, and supply chain disruption: These factors can all contribute to project delays, cost overruns, and increased risk.
Claims and Loss Trends
Loss experience across UK commercial construction is characterized by a mix of medium-frequency attritional losses and a small number of very expensive, multi-trigger events. MGAs should pay closer attention to:
- Severity vs frequency: Understanding the severity and frequency of losses is crucial for effective risk management.
- Long-tail exposures: Long-tail exposures can have significant implications for insurers and MGAs.
- Fire losses and professional indemnity overlaps: Fire losses and professional indemnity overlaps can increase the complexity and cost of claims.

Risk Selection and Information Quality
Effective risk selection requires high-quality underwriting information. MGAs should insist on:
- Dynamic, project-specific information: Information should be dynamic and reflective of the project’s specific risks and challenges.
- Regular updates and monitoring: Regular updates and monitoring can help MGAs stay informed about project developments and risks.
Takeaways and Next Steps
After reading this article, MGAs should think differently about commercial construction risks and their implications for underwriting and risk management. If you’d like to discuss further or explore how to improve your risk selection and management processes, please reach out to Rare Earth Partners.


